Policy Recommendations on the Draft Amended Land Law: Mechanisms for Resolving Land Disputes, Complaints and Denunciations

Insights · 22 September 2026

Lawyer Do Trong Hai argues that Vietnam should move from a system that mainly “processes land-related petitions” to a modern system for “preventing and resolving land disputes”: separating civil disputes from disputes with the State, professionalizing mediation, dealing with historical legacies and holding land authorities accountable.

Hanoi, 22 September 2026. Prepared by: Lawyer Do Trong Hai, Director and Managing Partner, Bizlink Lawyers.

I. INTRODUCTION

The resolution of land-related disputes, complaints and denunciations is among the most difficult and sensitive areas of land law. Unlike many ordinary legal relationships, land disputes often involve an interplay of property, administrative, historical, family, community and livelihood considerations. An administrative decision concerning land may directly affect people's homes, means of production and a substantial proportion of their accumulated assets.

The 2024 Land Law devotes Articles 235–238 to conciliation, jurisdiction over dispute resolution, complaints, administrative lawsuits and denunciations. Notably, Article 235 provides for conciliation at the commune-level People's Committee before a competent authority resolves a dispute, within a period not exceeding 30 days. Article 237 affirms the right of land users and persons with related rights and obligations to lodge complaints or institute legal proceedings against administrative decisions or acts concerning land administration.

From 1 July 2026, the legal framework governing complaints and denunciations has also been amended by Law No. 136/2025/QH15, which amends the Law on Citizen Reception, the Law on Complaints and the Law on Denunciations. One noteworthy development is the introduction of online citizen reception, better aligned with the requirements of digital transformation.

However, the more important question is not simply whether there are sufficient legal provisions for resolving disputes, but rather: How can a mechanism be designed to ensure that land disputes are resolved promptly, objectively and independently, with a high degree of predictability, and are genuinely brought to a definitive conclusion?

In my view, this should be the central criterion guiding further improvements to land legislation.

II. RECONSIDERING THE NATURE OF LAND DISPUTES AND LAND-RELATED CLAIMS

A long-standing limitation is that land disputes, complaints and denunciations have generally been approached primarily as "downstream problems": when a dispute arises, procedures are devised to resolve it; when a complaint is lodged, rules identify the authority responsible for handling it.

This approach is insufficient.

Most land disputes are the ultimate manifestation of "upstream" problems, such as inaccurate cadastral records; complex histories of land use; incorrectly issued or overlapping certificates; opaque planning; land recovery that has failed to secure public consensus; contentious land valuations and compensation; planning changes that create enormous disparities in value; protracted administrative procedures; or administrative decisions left unresolved for years.

Accordingly, the policy objective should not merely be to improve the efficiency of dispute resolution, but rather to:

prevent disputes from arising – resolve them promptly when they do arise – and ensure that disputes, once resolved, are genuinely brought to an end.

From this perspective, reform of land-dispute resolution mechanisms must be pursued alongside reform of land registration, cadastral data, planning, land valuation, land recovery and public administration.

III. DRAWING A CLEARER DISTINCTION BETWEEN CIVIL LAND DISPUTES AND DISPUTES WITH THE STATE

This is a matter of fundamental importance.

In essence, land-related disputes may be divided into two broad categories.

The first comprises disputes between parties standing on an equal legal footing: disputes over boundaries, land use rights, transfer contracts, inheritance, mortgages, capital contributions, and rights in assets attached to land, among others.

The second comprises disputes between individuals or businesses and the State concerning land-administration decisions or actions: land recovery, land allocation, land leases, issuance or revocation of certificates, compensation, assistance, resettlement and determination of financial obligations.

These two categories differ fundamentally in nature and require different dispute-resolution mechanisms.

For the first category, the courts must play the central role.

For the second, citizens must be entitled to request administrative authorities to reconsider their decisions, while also enjoying effective access to an independent adjudicative mechanism.

The current Land Law already recognizes the right to lodge complaints or institute legal proceedings against administrative decisions and acts relating to land management. In the longer term, however, further reforms should be explored to reduce the number of administrative layers through which a case must pass before reaching a final, stable determination.

An important guiding principle should be:

The authority issuing an administrative decision has both the right and the responsibility to review and correct its own errors; but where the dispute remains unresolved at that stage, citizens must have a short and effective route to an independent adjudicative body.

IV. ELEVATING MEDIATION FROM A "PROCEDURAL STEP" TO A SUBSTANTIVE DISPUTE-RESOLUTION MECHANISM

The 2024 Land Law continues to attach importance to mediation. Article 235 provides for commune-level land-dispute mediation councils, comprising representatives of the People's Committee, the Vietnam Fatherland Front and cadastral officials, and potentially persons familiar with the origin and history of the land's use. Decree No. 102/2024/ND-CP also provides for verification of the origin, history and current status of land use, as well as the persons who may be invited to participate in mediation.

This is a sound direction, but the quality of mediation needs further improvement.

In many complex cases, commune-level officials lack the professional expertise to address issues such as decades of changes in land use, maps from different periods, inheritance, civil transactions, changes to administrative boundaries, or inconsistencies between cadastral records and actual land use.

A model of professional land-dispute mediation should therefore be developed.

For high-value or complex disputes, parties should be able to select independent mediators, lawyers, cadastral specialists, valuation experts or professional mediation organizations.

In particular, a distinction must be drawn between mediating a dispute between private individuals and an administrative authority merely "persuading" citizens to accept its own decision. These are not the same.

An effective mediation mechanism must ensure the mediator's neutrality.

V. ESTABLISHING A DISPUTE-RESOLUTION MECHANISM THAT IS "SWIFT, INDEPENDENT AND PREDICTABLE"

This should be regarded as one of the overarching principles of reform.

The time taken to resolve a dispute is not merely a procedural matter. It carries substantial economic costs.

A parcel of land tied up in litigation for five to ten years may remain undeveloped, be incapable of normal transfer, face difficulties in obtaining credit, be unavailable for project development, and depress the value of the surrounding area.

Three reforms therefore merit consideration.

First, introduce expedited procedures for straightforward disputes.

Disputes concerning boundaries, minor discrepancies in area, correction of records, or cases in which cadastral evidence is clear need not necessarily follow the same process as complex disputes.

Second, promote specialization in the adjudication of land disputes.

Consideration should be given to establishing specialist land divisions or appointing judges specializing in land matters within the courts. Land is a highly technical field involving civil and administrative law, planning, construction, valuation and cadastral matters.

Third, systematically publish judgments, decisions and approaches to dispute resolution.

A healthy land market requires predictability.

In principle, similar cases should be handled according to reasonably consistent standards. Developing case law, judicial guidance and databases of anonymized decisions would help citizens, businesses, lawyers and regulators better anticipate legal consequences.

VI. ADDRESSING THE PROBLEM OF AUTHORITIES "ACTING AS BOTH PLAYER AND REFEREE" IN ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINTS

An institutional design issue that must be confronted candidly is the objectivity of complaint-resolution mechanisms.

In many cases, the challenged decision originates within the administrative system itself, while its reconsideration also takes place primarily within that same system.

It is necessary for administrative authorities to be able to review their own decisions. Yet internal review cannot fully replace independent oversight.

Over the longer term, therefore, the courts' role in reviewing land-related administrative decisions should be strengthened, and access to justice must be available to citizens at reasonable cost and within a reasonable time.

For particularly complex cases involving land prices, compensation or planning, consideration could be given to engaging independent experts to assist adjudicative bodies.

VII. MAKING LAND DATA THE CORE INFRASTRUCTURE OF THE DISPUTE-RESOLUTION SYSTEM

A significant proportion of land disputes arise from incomplete, inconsistent or inaccessible records.

Reform of dispute-resolution mechanisms must therefore go hand in hand with reform of land data.

I propose moving towards the principle that every land parcel should have a unique identifier linking the following data layers:

Land parcel – Land user / owner of attached assets – Planning – Construction – Tax – Mortgage – Transactions – Disputes.

When a dispute arises, the court or competent authority should be able to obtain prompt access to the parcel's complete legal history.

Historical records should also be progressively digitized, including maps, land inventory registers, certificate issuance files, land allocation and recovery records, and changes occurring over successive periods.

This is particularly important because Decree No. 102/2024/ND-CP already recognizes that maps, cadastral records and remote-sensing imagery from different periods may be used in resolving disputes.

A robust data system will not only accelerate dispute resolution but also prevent disputes from arising in the first place.

VIII. DEALING SEPARATELY WITH "HISTORICAL LEGACIES" IN LAND MATTERS

This is perhaps the most difficult issue.

Vietnam has numerous cases in which land use has continued across successive legal regimes, with incomplete documentation or actual use that has diverged substantially from the original records.

If these matters continue to be addressed solely through ordinary case-by-case procedures, some historical problems may persist for decades to come.

Consideration should therefore be given to a national programme to resolve outstanding historical land issues within a defined period, for example five to ten years.

The first step should be to classify these outstanding issues, rather than handling individual petitions in isolation.

Possible categories include:

(i) land used stably over a long period but lacking supporting documents;

(ii) land allocated without proper authority in earlier periods;

(iii) discrepancies between maps, certificates and actual conditions;

(iv) disputes originating from state agricultural and forestry farms;

(v) land associated with long-stalled projects;

(vi) protracted complaints and litigation concerning land recovery, compensation and resettlement; and

(vii) old administrative decisions that no longer reflect actual conditions but have never been conclusively addressed.

Each category should have its own set of resolution criteria.

Article 108 of Decree No. 102/2024/ND-CP already permits consideration of multiple factors when resolving disputes involving land without documentation, including evidence of the origin and history of land use, current conditions, planning, and rules on land allocation, leasing and recognition of land use rights. This pragmatic approach should be further developed.

For historical land issues, the law should decisively move away from asking:

"What do the old records say?"

and towards a more balanced inquiry:

"What solution is required by lawful rights and interests, actual patterns of use, the public interest and the present need for social stability?"

This does not mean legalizing every historical violation. On the contrary, a clear distinction must be made between good-faith land users and those who have encroached upon land or deliberately violated the law.

IX. A SPECIAL MECHANISM FOR LONG-STANDING COMPLAINTS AND LITIGATION

A case that has remained unresolved for ten or twenty years should not continue to be processed under the very procedures that failed to resolve it during the preceding ten or twenty years.

A special review mechanism for long-standing unresolved cases should be explored.

Inter-agency task forces could be established at provincial or central level for particularly complex categories of cases, involving land administration, judicial and inspection authorities and, where necessary, independent experts.

The objective is not to reopen final decisions indefinitely, but to establish a screening and resolution mechanism for cases showing signs of serious error, legal inconsistency or manifest and persistent unreasonableness.

This mechanism must be accompanied by the principles of finality and closure.

A sound legal system must secure both values: the ability to correct mistakes and the ability to bring disputes to an end.

X. LINKING DISPUTE RESOLUTION TO THE ACCOUNTABILITY OF LAND-ADMINISTRATION AUTHORITIES AND OFFICIALS

Where a particular type of dispute recurs repeatedly in a locality, attention must be paid not only to individual cases but also to the governance failures that give rise to them.

For example, if hundreds of complaints stem from the same type of land-recovery decision or the same method of calculating compensation, the system should be capable of identifying a systemic problem rather than continuing to process hundreds of separate files.

Decree No. 102/2024/ND-CP already includes the resolution of disputes, complaints and denunciations within the monitoring and evaluation of land management and use. In my view, a further step is needed.

A land-dispute monitoring system should be established, with locality-based statistics covering:

the number of new cases; types of disputes; average resolution time; successful mediation rates; proportions of administrative decisions amended or annulled; numbers of cases requiring reconsideration; numbers of unexecuted judgments; and common underlying causes.

These data should become indicators for assessing the quality of local land governance.

XI. CLEARLY DISTINGUISHING COMPLAINTS FROM DENUNCIATIONS

Complaints and denunciations serve different functions.

A complaint seeks to protect the rights and interests of a person affected by an administrative decision or act.

A denunciation seeks to expose and address violations of the law.

The current Land Law recognizes the right of individuals to denounce violations of land-management and land-use laws, with such denunciations handled in accordance with the law on denunciations.

Accordingly, the denunciation mechanism should not be used as an alternative means of indefinitely prolonging disputes or complaints that have already been resolved through proper procedures.

Conversely, where a complaint reveals indications of corruption, falsification of records, collusion for private gain or deliberate unlawful conduct in land administration, there must be a mechanism for referring the matter to the appropriate inspection, investigation or denunciation process.

Keeping these mechanisms distinct would significantly reduce the circulation of petitions from one authority to another.

XII. SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the foregoing analysis, I propose consideration of a reform package built around the following pillars:

1. Establish swift, objective, independent and highly predictable land-dispute resolution as a guiding principle of land law.

2. Clearly distinguish civil land disputes from administrative disputes concerning land management, reducing overlaps in jurisdiction.

3. Strengthen the role of independent adjudication while preserving administrative authorities' ability to review and promptly correct their own errors.

4. Professionalize land mediation by allowing lawyers, cadastral specialists, valuers and independent mediators to participate in complex cases.

5. Promote specialization in land adjudication, develop a cadre of specialist judges and strengthen arrangements for expert assistance.

6. Introduce expedited procedures for straightforward disputes supported by clear evidence.

7. Build an integrated land database based on a unique identifier for each parcel, linked to planning, construction, taxation, mortgages, transactions and disputes.

8. Establish a national programme to address historical land issues, classifying problems and prescribing distinct resolution criteria for each category.

9. Introduce a special review mechanism for long-standing unresolved cases, while defining a clear endpoint to safeguard the stability of land relations.

10. Develop data systems and indicators for land disputes and complaints, using the volume and quality of dispute resolution as measures of local governance performance.

11. Enhance the accountability of administrative authorities, particularly for decisions annulled by courts or found unlawful by competent authorities.

12. Strengthen enforcement of dispute-resolution outcomes, since even a legally correct decision that is not implemented promptly does not constitute effective protection of rights. Decree No. 102/2024/ND-CP already contains provisions on requests for enforcement and compulsory enforcement of dispute-resolution decisions; these mechanisms must be made effective in practice.

XIII. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Reform of the mechanisms for resolving land disputes, complaints and denunciations should not be regarded merely as reform of a set of administrative or judicial procedures. It is an integral part of the institutional framework governing land administration and the real estate market.

A modern land system is not one in which disputes never arise. What matters is that, when disputes do arise, they are identified early and resolved swiftly, objectively and independently, at reasonable cost and with a genuine prospect of final resolution.

More fundamentally, the objective of reform must shift from:

"resolving more disputes"

to:

"creating a governance system in which fewer disputes arise."

To achieve this, reforms must simultaneously address land data, registration of rights, planning, valuation, land recovery and compensation, administrative procedures, mediation, adjudication and enforcement of decisions.

Historical issues call for a more pragmatic approach. Shortcomings originating decades ago cannot be allowed to pass from one generation to the next merely because the system lacks a sufficiently effective mechanism to bring them to a close. At the same time, their resolution must be grounded in the rule of law, clearly distinguish legitimate rights and interests from unlawful conduct, and ensure fairness between those who comply with the law and those who have committed violations.

If the entire reform agenda were to be distilled into one overarching requirement, I would put it as follows:

Vietnam needs to move from a system primarily concerned with "processing land-related petitions" to a modern system for "preventing and resolving land disputes" that is data-driven, transparent and professional, and supported by a sufficiently robust mechanism of independent adjudication.

This is essential not only to better protect the lawful rights and interests of citizens and businesses, but also to strengthen confidence in land governance, reduce the social costs of disputes, unlock land resources and build a transparent, stable and healthy real estate market.